Choosing
Good Points
There are a number of things that you can all do to make sure that the
points you are making in your essay are good ones. Follow the guidelines below
to help you choose good main points for your plan.
1. Keep it
general
A good essay should contain only 4 tor 6 main points (although these
will be broken down into smaller sub-points). These points should be very high
level so that you can then go into much more depth underneath them.
If one of your main points is the reference to the use of the word ‘Peacock’
in the text then you are going to run out of depth very quickly. There’s not
much more you can say about it once you have talked about the colourful and vibrant connotations of the words.
Instead you need a more general main point to start with – something
like the
use of bright, vibrant, exotic description to create a lively, vivacious and
fascinating impression of Pakistan or
the fact that both ‘Disabled’ and ‘Out
Out’ evoke a mood of poignant melancholy but that Disabled reflects on the
shattered illusions of the young soldier while ‘Out Out’ reveals the brevity
and fragility of all life. Underneath the first main point, for
example, you could then go on to discuss the symbol of the peacock which
suggests the beauty and elegance of Pakistan, the rich colours
and textures of the clothes and the contrast with the awkward and ‘tilt’ing West.
2. Look for
links
A good point will link up different points from throughout the two poems
that are related in some way. However, a link doesn’t just have to join up
things that do the same job – you can draw links between ideas are the complete
opposite or each other. In point two above, for example, you can see that there
is a similarity in that there is a sense of sadness created in both poems but
the point then goes on to explore the important ways in which these poems are
different.
3. Variety of
evidence
Commenting on how the connotations of words, their sounds, their
complexity, their length, etc, all work together to create a certain effect.
See the examples on the ‘Making Points’ page.
4. Be
interesting
You should attempt to make some interesting, unusual or unexpected
points to make the examiner think that you’ve really understood what’s going
on. This can be hard because these poems are fairly straightforward but you
could try to comment on the lives of the poets or the historical context at the
time of writing which may have influenced the poem.
Another good way of making interesting points is by pointing out how two
things are superficially different but at a deeper level very similar. Or,
alternatively, how things are superficially similar but at a deeper level very
different.
One final way of making good points is to understand that some things
can be interpreted in a number of ways and to point out the existence of and
evidence for both interpretations. A really good candidate will sometimes go on
to explain why the poet may have wanted to leave their poem ambiguous (i.e.
with more than one meaning).