Discuss the Ways in which Owen conveys the Loss of
Human Dignity in ‘Dulce et Decorum Est’
During the World
War One, many terrible, inhumane events took place which resulted in the
reduction of people’s status as human beings - making people lose their sense
of self-value and pride. ‘Dulce et Decorum Est’ by Wilfred Owen, is on the
topic of war and investigates and conveys the loss of human dignity. The poem
has a persona who addresses the reader directly. This in itself is effective in
the involvement of the reader and helps significantly in conveying the loss of
human dignity in times of war.
‘Dulce et
Decorum Est’, focuses mainly on the physical suffering of the soldier persona
who is telling the story as well as his friends, and the experiences which the
regiment went through, not least of which was seeing a comrade gassed to death.
The main message of the poem is a warning to the public about telling ‘with
such high zest…The Old Lie’, and how war was not the least bit like they
imagined.
‘Dulce et Decorum
Est’ has four stanzas, two of which have the same number of lines (eight) and
rhyming pattern, but the middle two stanzas are in fact one with a break before
the second-last line. The short stanza of two lines looks irregular and
stresses the impression the event made on the writer. This impression is one of
emotional trauma and horror at the events that had come to pass: an effective
demonstration of the loss of human dignity.
‘Dulce et
Decorum Est’ focuses on inhumanity during wartime through the use of imagery
and graphic descriptions from the persona. The poem first concentrates more on
the physical suffering of the regiment than anything else, the persona relays how
the men were all ‘bent double, like old beggars under sacks’. The choice of
words creates a vivid image in the reader’s mind, and there is no subtlety -
the line conveys the loss of dignity all too clearly. The people fighting the
war are meant to be strong young men but the war seems to have aged them
terribly.
The soldiers
were ‘knock-kneed, coughing like hags’, a vivid image which implies that they did
not care any longer what they looked like, much less acted like and they in
fact cared only about getting to their ‘distant rest’. This creates the effect
of single-minded animals plodding along, in clear contrast to the image of
gallant war heroes that had been used to cajole young men into enlisting in the
army. The use of ‘trudge’ hints that they are not only trudging to their base
for a brief respite from fighting but perhaps are trudging slowly to their
deaths.
Due to the
fact that Owen’s poem describes events that had already taken place, and that
he himself had experienced, he is able to include explicitly realistic
images of the conditions the soldiers faced; he says that ‘all went lame, all
blind’. Robbed of their senses through fatigue or sustaining injuries, the
soldiers are nothing more than a straggling line of dependent elderly people,
in fact ‘lame’ even suggests that they are little better than animals. The
mention of ‘all’ in the line was also quite significant in suggesting that
nobody, whether they wanted to or not, could escape from the repercussions of
the war.
In some
parts of the poem, the soldiers are made to seem like a group of empty shells,
or programmed automatons, who were ‘deaf even to the hoots of gas-shells
dropping’, and hence unable, or simply too fatigued to realize that they were in
danger. It is almost as though they are passive, emotionless beings that have
seen too much to feel anything anymore, even when put into a potentially fatal
circumstance.
The
intensely painful death that the gassed soldier experiences is conveyed through
the image of being ‘like a man in fire or lime’ where the use of simple similes
that the reader can readily grasp helps to make real the horrors of war to the
audience at home. The use of ‘lime’, with its bleach-like, burning, alkaline
connotations is the substance used to cover dead bodies when they are buried in
mass graves to hide the smell of decomposition and quickly disintegrate the
corpses so as to prevent the spread of disease. This perhaps foreshadows not
only the death of the soldier but also his later brutal and inhuman treatment
as he is ‘flung’ into a wagon still ‘writhing’ in his death throes perhaps only
to be later buried in a mass grave, unidentified and ignominious along with all
the other soldiers who entered the war expecting a noble death but were instead
awarded with treatment no better than that granted to an animal carcass.
The two-line
stanza stands alone and accentuates the impression the gassed man made on the
writer: ‘he plunges at me, guttering, choking, drowning.’ The triad here emphasises
the impression of a desperate plea for help, a plea so moving that in the
writer’s ‘smothering dreams’, ‘before his helpless sight’, he still sees the
dying man. This powerful moment makes the reader acutely aware of the horror
that many soldiers had to face as they watched their fellows die, instinctively
wanting to help their comrades but unable to do anything except stand there
like an animal caught in the glare of headlights.
The use of
the Latin motto ‘Dulce et Decorum Est Pro Patria Mori’ is particularly
effective as at the time the poem was written, the public would have known what
it meant, and would have expected a poem praising war. The dashing of these
expectations as the reader reads the poem powerfully conveys the loss of human
dignity in wartime; the reader is told the ‘Lie’ that they have always believed
and then the illusion is stripped from them. The poem ends with the Latin word
‘mori’, meaning ‘to die’, and lends an ominous note to an already grave poem.
Essentially,
the poem encompasses the atrocities of war and the loss of human dignity endured
by the soldiers who experienced the horrific conditions on the battlefield.
However, a more significant loss of human dignity is hinted at by the Latin title
and final line, a motto which fuelled the hopes of ‘children ardent for some
desperate glory’, making fools of them as they plunged headlong into the front
lines of battle not realizing the truth until it was too late. The ultimate
indignity is that these soldiers were lead to their deaths like fools and even
had a hand in their own damnation as they enlisted of their own free will.
‘Dulce et
Decorum Est’ is a powerful poem which expresses the inhumanity of war and the
loss of human dignity resulting from the horrific suffering experienced by the
soldiers on the front lines. Owen’s personal experience of war and his attempt to
tell his story from a perspective that contradicted the common view of his time
makes his poem moving and poignant, a pathos only added to by his own tragic
death shortly before less than a week before the end of the war. As a result,
Owen’s poem thoroughly convinces the reader of the loss of human dignity caused
by war.