‘What impression is created of war by Owen in his poem Dulce et Decorum
Est?
Main Point 1 – Owen’s depiction of the powerlessness of their soldiers
Evidence:
‘knock-kneed’, ‘bent-double’, ‘old beggars’, ‘coughing like hags’, ‘all
lame, all blind’
Explanation: These
words undermine the image of hearty and brave young soliders
·
‘bent-double’
suggests old age and that the soldiers are almost collapsing under the strain
of life in the trenches
·
‘knock-kneed’
sounds diseased or arthritic and the onomatopoeic sound suggests fear
·
‘beggars’
obviously live in horrible, poor conditions and it is as if they are begging
for their lives
·
‘coughing’
suggests diseased and hags are an unpleasant image of decrepit old women
·
‘all lame’ lame
is a term often applied to animals, suggesting that the soldiers are no better
than animals
Evidence: ‘trudge’
and ‘sludge’, the repetitive and monotonous ABAB rhyme scheme
Explanation: The
dull and heavy sounds seem to lack energy and any life
·
the guttural
‘udge’ sounds conjure an image of people’s feet being stuck in the mud and
difficult to move
·
the guttural ‘u’
sound also seem animalistic and low in energy
·
the monotonous
rhyme scheme also suggests there is no escape from this repetitive slog through
mud
Evidence: ‘we
cursed through sludge’
Explanation: The
soldiers complain but carry on anyway
·
‘cursed’ suggests
that even though the soldiers are swearing about the horrible situation they
carry on anyway
·
‘cursed’ may also
suggest the soldiers are cursed and do not have the power to break free of this
spell
Evidence:
‘helpless sight’, ‘plunges at me guttering, choking, drowning.’
Explanation: Being
able to only stand by and watch their friends die suggests exactly how
powerless they are
·
‘helpless’ is obviously powerless, but it’s as if the soldier
is forced to see this again and again in his dreams. Not only was he powerless
to help the first time but he is powerless to stop the dreams coming back too
·
‘plunges’
suggests the desperation of the friend making it even more tragic that the
solider couldn’t help
·
the triad of ‘guttering, choking, drowning’ suggests that
this man did not die a quick death and instead slowly drowned. This slow death
must have been horrific to watch and thus, even more tragic for the solider to
witness
Evidence:
‘in all my dreams’, ‘smothering dreams’
Explanation: The
dreams are made to seem overpowering, as if experiences in the war have
permanently scarred the soldiers
·
The repetition of
dreams suggest they recur again and again and are inescapable
·
The connotations
of ‘smothering’ suggest the dreams are overwhelming, almost suffocating